I picked these up at an antique store in Ohio. They cleaned up really nicely (the ring was stuck on the one when I bought them, and still only barely fits one way). The one has no damage, the other has a clean slice off one end from top to bottom. The glass is lumpy and both have steam wisps in them, the damaged one has a thin amber line that circles the hole. These have conical depressions in the bottom rather than cylindrical.